Search This Blog

Tuesday, October 29, 2019

Updated: Don't let the mayor's "shiny object" distract you. She is playing fast and loose with city funds

            Editor’s note: This blog item has been updated from one posted earlier today in order to reflect changes in documentation provided by Cheyenne Mayor Marian Orr. The earlier post doubted the mayor’s assertion that an accounting log was proof that she had paid for a limousine ride, not a massage, as indicated by City Council President Rocky Case. She has since provided a digital receipt. But that does not change the theme of this post: that Orr is trying to distract residents from her misuse of city funds.

BY D. REED ECKHARDT

If Cheyenne Mayor Marian Orr thinks her latest foray into political theater will have any impact on her critics, she had better think again. 
And again.
            Because last week’s press conference where she tried to discredit Council President Rocky Case was pure bull manure. It was designed to do just one thing: toss a “shiny object” into the air with hopes that residents will focus on that rather than on her mishandling of public funds. (You can view the mayor’s press conference at https://cutt.ly/vexlq4b)
Does Cheyenne’s
Mayor Orr speaks to the press last week.
mayor really think the people of this city are stupid? That they can be distracted from her own ethical failings by some ginned up tale of a personal vendetta? Apparently so. And this is a reminder – again – of the arrogance that continues to plague her administration.
            For those who missed the mayor’s most recent bit of drama, last Friday Orr tried to first assert that Case – and a local radio station – were dead wrong when they implied a receipt proved she had abused the public trust by using tax dollars to get a massage at the airport in Detroit, Mich. She now has been proven right about that. She now has produced a $64 digital receipt from a limousine company that she said she used, though her initial documentation – an accounting log – was weak at best. 
            But Orr then went on to paint Case as a “momma’s boy,” someone who is out to “get her.” But not because she has been abusing city funds – which she clearly has been doing, at least when it comes to her misuse of the $100,000 Bloomberg grant. Rather, she asserted Case bears a grudge for her getting his mother, former City Council member Judy Case, fired from her position as a staff member at the Legislature.
            Really? 
            This is the strategy employed all too often now by politicians at the national level. Rather than deal with the matter at hand, they throw up some kind of distraction. In that way, the voters’ eyes are turned from the politician’s ethical misdealings and toward something fresh and exciting. The hope is that the ethical matters will quickly fade into the background.
            For Orr, the “shiny object” is her phony story of Rocky Case’s vendetta against her. Her assertion is that the council president is not motivated by a desire to uncover corruption in the mayor’s office but rather by payback for the way his mother has been treated. It is designed to minimize the mayor’s own misbehavior. 
For the record, Orr’s story is filled with errors. Judy Case, the council president’s mother, was not let go at the Legislature “20 years ago” as the mayor claimed at her press conference. Judy Case served on the City Council until 2010, and was still, if memory serves me, working at the Legislature well after that. She also never was censured by the City Council as Orr said, though Judy Case was reprimanded for her behavior at a committee meeting. (Sitting council member Pete Laybourn was officially censured by the council around the same time).
True, Judy Case was let go at the Legislature, and Orr reportedly had a role in that. But the mayor’s story is full of holes. She needs to do her homework before trying to distract the people of this city.
But assume for a moment that this is a personal vendetta by Rocky Case (an assumption not accepted here, by the way). What does it matter what the president’s motivation is? How does that nullify the fact that Orr misspent grants funds (she still has not apologized for that nor for the stain that has left on the city’s reputation)? It doesn’t. 
Orr has “proven” nothing, and that has not undermined Case’s argument that she is misusing city funds for her own personal ends. Indeed, his catching her arms deep in the Bloomberg cookie jar (remember, the city is being required to repay $56,571, at least partly because of Orr’s use of it for such things as airline tickets and bar tabs) tends to support Case, and not Orr, in this dispute. (Check out a post on this concern at https://cutt.ly/iexliXQ)
And if the mayor were to use taxpayer funds to get her nails done or get a massage in Detroit, it wouldn’t surprise anyone. Orr’s ethical failings, such as accepting a gift from a potential city supplier, are a matter of public record that can’t be disappeared by this new “shiny object.” 
Orr is simply hoping the people of Cheyenne will take their eyes off the facts and focus on the process, implying that if the process of revealing the facts is flawed, the facts have to be flawed as well.
But nothing could be further from the truth. The facts continue to mount that Orr is playing fast and loose with city funds. Rocky Case says there is more to come – he has binders of receipts on his council desk that he is going through – which certainly is why the mayor is using the shiny object of Judy Case to distract the voters and taxpayers from whatever might be coming next.
As a piece of theatrical politics, Orr’s press conference was a flop. Rather than diverting attention from her unethical behavior, it has drawn the focus to her ever tighter. Now she knows the people of Cheyenne are watching, which is bound to put a crimp in her lifestyle. Poor baby. She may have to use her own $95,000 salary rather than other taxpayer dollars to pay her bar tabs.

D. Reed Eckhardt is the former executive editor of the Wyoming Tribune Eagle.

12 comments:

  1. Reed, do a better Google search. I did, and found the Relax N Go taxi company pretty easily. I spoke to the owner of the company and they routinely go from downtown Detroit to the airport.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're apparently better than everyone else at finding the place on Google. Would you mind providing a link?

      Delete
    2. Hi Reed,

      This is Dave Lerner, now of The Cheyenne Post. I didn't realize I would show up as Unknown. I Googled "Relax N Go" with quotes. They don't have a website. It is a family run taxi business in Detroit. The family is Chowdhoury. I spoke to Mohammed Chowdhoury, who is the owner, and confirmed that they are a taxi company and do run from downtown Detroit to the airport. I didn't ask specifically if he carried Marian Orr. The ride in question is almost exactly a year ago, and I didn't know what hotel she stayed in. Scroll down on this page until you see Mohammed's listing: https://www.fastpeoplesearch.com/address/4498-sobieski-st_detroit-mi-48212

      Delete
    3. Feel free to google maps has address then use street view. The very crowded street even has a taxi on it. Thank you Dave.

      Delete
    4. That's interesting because when I Google "Relax N Go" just as you suggested, I get several options for Relax N Go Message, which is a message chair service. Oh, and by the way, there just happens to be one in the Detroit airport.

      Delete
    5. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    6. When I google "relax n go", I see the following:
      Appointment scheduler for a Relax N Go in Indianna
      Relax N Go in Chicago
      Relax N Go in Pennsylvania
      An instagram page for the Indianna Relax N Go
      A Pictame pointing at the instagram for the Relax N Go in Indianna
      Links to Relax N Go in Ambler, PA

      What I don't see is a link to Detroit. When I found the taxi service it was because I was looking in Detroit. Here's the thing about shitty research, it is almost as bad as shitty spelling. It doesn't help the 'Orr is cORRupt' team at all. In fact, it lays doubt on all things people can prove she does do wrong. Not to mention that a few days ago the receipt for the taxi service was provided by the mayor, discussed in this blog article, as well as admitted to its existance in the press by Rocky Case himself.

      Quit trying to prove something that is false. Orr sucks. She doesn't need you helping her look better with poor research and false accusations.

      Delete
  2. Actually there is a Relax N Go Taxi service that is a one man operation running out of Hamtramck, MI which makes much more sense considering Hamtramck is smack dab in the middle of Detroit and the charge is from a square account. But don't stop. The mayor is indeed shit. But playing this up like it is her personal vendetta and not just an attempted power grab from the 'other' good old boy network here in town is absurd. Truth to power? You should change the name of this blog as it's not really truth but glorified opinion pieces.

    ReplyDelete
  3. A second note... Relax N Go and Be Relax (the name of the spa company at the airport) are pretty different names. Yes, both companies use the same word, but is that enough for this confusion?

    ReplyDelete
  4. And...Mr Case has now stated he has seen the actual receipt.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I don't think your correction: For those who missed the mayor’s most recent bit of drama, last Friday Orr tried to first assert that Case – and a local radio station – were dead wrong when they implied a receipt proved she had abused the public trust by using tax dollars to get a massage at the airport in Detroit, Mich. She now has been proven right about that.

    Helps the rest of the case you are trying to make. She defended herself against a false accusation, and you're calling that a "shiny object"? Case insinuated a sleazy act on the part of the Mayor and he was dead wrong. Why isn't he being called on the carpet for making a false accusation in the first place? A better column would be on why Case needs to stoop so low to attack the Mayor. As you point out, there are legitimate mistakes she has made. But that shouldn't open her up to false accusations, and as your column tries to say, defending herself is wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi everyone, I saw comments from people who had already got their loan from
    Unit Loan Offer. Honestly I thought it was a scam, and then I decided
    to make a request based on their recommendations. A few days ago, I
    confirmed in my personal bank account amounting to 15,000 $ , which I
    requested for business. This is really good news and I am so happy that I
    advise all those who need a real loan and who are sure to reimburse to
    apply through their email (unitloanoffer@gmail.com) There are sincere
    loan lenders!

    They are able to lend you a loan.
    Contact: Unit Loan Offer
    E-mail: unitloanoffer@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete